U.S. Agencies Weighed Atomic Attack on China in 1950s f[w jur
Secrets: CIA documents say weapons use could have shown Western determination in Korean War. #h}IUR
October 01, 1993|JIM MANN, TIMES STAFF WRITER $L $j
KNwf
d{( s-
WASHINGTON — U.S. intelligence agencies weighed seriously the possible impact of using nuclear weapons against China during the Korean War and after the French defeat in Indochina, according to newly declassified CIA files. hA$c.jJr.Z
Ta!m% =8
"If atomic weapons were used, the Communists would recognize the employment of these weapons as indicative of Western determination to carry the Korean War to a successful conclusion," the CIA and other intelligence agencies concluded in June, 1953. Uj
y6vgU;
j=zU7wz)D
This dispassionate analysis of a possible U.S. nuclear attack is contained in a series of files that the CIA made public Thursday. +^o3}`
Mr@<ZTw
The release was the initial step in the agency's effort to open up to historians and the American public a few of its archives from the early days of the Cold War. [0(
E>vm
@8T
Vr2uy
Overall, the documents demonstrate that during the tense Cold War period of the late 1940s and early 1950s, American intelligence was sometimes prescient and sometimes wildly inaccurate. +sV# Z,
j@!B OL~?
The CIA was able to predict accurately Soviet behavior in the Middle East during the Suez Canal crisis of 1956. Lcm
~QF7cd
#w[ q.+A
Soviet officials had suggested that Moscow might intervene militarily in response to the invasion of Egypt by Israel, France and Britain. A hurried U.S. intelligence estimate concluded, correctly, that the Soviet Union would not attack Britain or France and would not send its forces to the Middle East. Zi15wE
w0F:%:/
Agency officials also suggested the possibility of a Sino-Soviet split several years before it occurred. bUEt0wRR
2\kC_o97
The study warned, however, that the Soviet Union and China would stick together through the period of the early 1950s--as in fact they did. |^>L`6 uo
fbW,0
But American intelligence also had notable failures, the files show. 6Vu}k K)
5+#?7J 1
It failed to predict the outbreak of war in North Korea in a study completed just before the conflict began. The CIA said only that North Korean forces "have a capability for attaining limited objectives in short-term military operations against southern Korea." The Pyongyang regime launched its devastatingly successful invasion of the south six days later, and the war lasted until 1953. mRix0XBI~
?}!gLp
In the wildest miscalculation of all, the CIA gazed into its crystal ball in 1953 and hazarded a guess on the future course of the Cold War. In many ways, U.S. intelligence officials concluded, "time must be said to be on the Soviet side."
